Escaping the illusion of hell by Bec
Monday, February 27, 2023
Images
Friday, February 24, 2023
Babylon
You can have a boob flash movie in which ultimate lesson is that Babylon wasn't really all it was cracked up to be. I just watched Babylon, all 3 hours of it, including the Tree of Life hallucinatory ending.
Babylon in the Bible: "Noah’s great-grandson, Nimrod, was the first mighty man of the Bible (Genesis 10:10), and the Bible says Babel was one of the towns that encompassed the beginning of Nimrod’s kingdom in the land of Shinar." (source)
Tangent, have you ever seen that documentary about a high school basketball team called Nimrod Nation?
"The people who erected the Tower of Babel decided to make a name for themselves in opposition to God, and they proceeded with outright disdain for God’s rule. That in and of itself was enough to make them evil because they clearly defied the Lord. Babylon’s god was Marduk, one they considered the supreme deity over all others."
In Buddhism Mara is the great distractor from the goal of the path. You could say just about everyone but a few monks are on the path, some pay respects, and it's fashionable to be mindful at work now, and everyone else ignores. You don't need to make a lot of bogeymen, cities and nations against enlightenment, because they're literally everywhere, including forces and instincts inside you. The inner Babylon of the heart.
Random Buddhist Link:
Great article by BBC on Nalanda University: "In the more-than seven centuries that Nalanda flourished, there was nothing else like it in the world. The monastic university predates the University of Oxford and Europe's oldest university, Bologna, by more than 500 years. What's more, Nalanda's enlightened approach to philosophy and religion would help shape the culture of Asia long after the university ceased to exist."
Random poem:
In Defense of Nothing
By Peter Gizzi
I guess these trailers lined up in the lot off the highway will do.
I guess that crooked eucalyptus tree also.
I guess this highway will have to do and the cars
and the people in them on their way.
The present is always coming up to us, surrounding us.
It’s hard to imagine atoms, hard to imagine
hydrogen & oxygen binding, it’ll have to do.
This sky with its macular clouds also
and that electric tower to the left, one line broken free.
Monday, February 20, 2023
Biases
“By & large, Kaccāna, this cosmos is in bondage to attachments, clingings/sustenances, & biases. But one such as this does not get involved with or cling to these attachments, clingings, fixations of awareness, biases, or obsessions; nor is he resolved on ‘my self.’ He has no uncertainty or doubt that mere stress, when arising, is arising; stress, when passing away, is passing away. In this, his knowledge is independent of others. It’s to this extent, Kaccāna, that there is right view.” -SN 12:15
Sunday, February 12, 2023
Saturday, January 28, 2023
Syncretism and traditionalism
Came across photos of Hercules protecting the Buddha. This is syncretism, the combining of traditions as the Silk Road connects early Buddhist culture with Greece. When you open up to the mythology of the whole world it's quite an exciting world.
The opposite of syncretism is fundamentalism. In fundamentalism you ward off combing ideas. Buddhism shouldn't combine with modern psychology. Buddhism shouldn't combine with secular ideas. We shouldn't care about the parallels with modern physics and Buddhism. Even Buddhism and Taoism or Confucianism shouldn't combine in early china. New age hippy ideas shouldn't be combined with Buddhism.
Closer to home, I think reliance on the guru in Vajrayana is Hinduism influence, perhaps. Buddha nature is Hinduism inspired, we are all god in some sects of Hinduism, OK we're all really Buddhas. Shake out what kind of interesting insights that might shake out. Pudgalavadins believe in a soul. Buddhism tries out other ideas in the history of Buddhism. Pure Land is an exploration of a kind of thinking, more reliance on other power.
We need self power, community power, and other power in the spiritual life because it is so demanding. There are some who believe the burning of oneself in protest isn't part of Buddhism. In a way the battle about what is and what isn't Buddhism is a constant battle. In Cambodia monks are brought up on heresy charges. In Europe there are blasphemy laws designed to protect Christianity being utilized for Buddhism.
I mean you can try to keep things pure and uninfluenced, and it's good to be clear what is what. To pretend like we're not influenced by everyone around us is silly. Materialism brought about by more fair economics is also a change in culture. The world is changing rapidly and yet humans need things to be the same, we are all profoundly psychologically conservative. Boredom is the emotion that drives us to challenge ourselves and try new things.
I can't help but think the spiritual life isn't where wars should be fought. The spiritual life can be focused on comfort, but it must also include an element of confrontation and discomfort. Not knowing and the negative capability can be used in the spiritual life.
People from traditional Theravadan countries sometimes see American adaptations of Buddhism as something they don't recognise, and can be offended by how it's being adapted. Some people want to have conflict over sects. There is a kind of branding war that smacks of materialism to me.
If there's no permanent self, can there be a permanent Buddhism? I think you can make mistakes, claim something is Buddhism and it's not, so I think there is a temporary essence, even if that is philosophically is problematic, it works psychologically. I keep coming back to the practices of community, devotion, study, ethics and meditation. Maybe it's my overly secularized influence, but I think Buddhism is more about what you do than what you claim to believe. Humans are complex and don't always act on their belief, we are hypocritical and unintegrated, confused, bewildered. Enacting ideals isn't easy. I also believe in authenticity over pretending you're more advanced than you really are.
Even if I am not a heritage Buddhist from a Buddhist country, and find secularizing interesting, doesn't mean that I can't be offended by McMindfulness and capitalism coopting the language of mindfulness to exploit workers better. I can even see traditionalist behavior as against Buddhist's quest for harmony. An over reliance on "right view" can seem like Christians hunting for blasphemy and dogma. Right view is the first step on the path, but like the first step in AA, is has to be constantly refreshed.
On page 80 of the Long Discourses the Buddha says to beware of eel wrigglers, people who can't be pinned down and won't express an honest commitment. Vagueness and superficiality are a problem.
My life experience matters, and the forced Christianity in America means I have little tolerance for what is Christian evangelical moves. Buddhism is supposed to change as it moves through new languages, new cultures, and new geography. But it still needs to be identifiable as Buddhism.
There is a point where Buddhism isn't just an individual sacred cherished aspect to a person and must enter out into the larger world. How involved in politics will it get? America is going through hype partisan times, as people don't understand that psychology pushes one to see the world in different ways, to see others hypocrisy, and not your own as much. It's the same old struggle in battling with yourself versus battling with the world. At the end of a soccer game, they play the song about how "everyone wants to rule the world."
Yes, maybe my white middle class male Buddhism is tinged with all those descriptors, but I still hope it reaches for something more universal, transcendent, and rooted. I like to think Buddhism isn't obsessed with gonads, flesh color and class, without deny those things are in play in the world, and not trying to silence anyone is expressing their experience about those things. I want to throw open my arms to everyone, metaphorically, but realize you can only see the people you see, in front of you, face to face. There are book Buddhists who just write on social media, but don't connect with sangha face to face. Everyone engages with Buddhism with their personality, history and culture.
Syncretism is unavoidable and therefore not unwelcome because resisting reality is a recipe for exhaustion, and errors. We both want to shoot for what we are not already and we must start where you are. It's about becoming, the glorious process of seeking.
Thursday, January 26, 2023
Abhassara Brahma
On page 75 of the Long Discourses (DN), my version translated by Maurice Walshe, there's a casual references to when the world contracts, everyone goes to Abhassara Brahma.
When I read about the cosmology of early Buddhism, I could find this article, which has a whole elaborate cosmology Dr. Ari Ubeysekara, and mentions it in context, complicated, rich setting. I feel overwhelmed and skeptical, like nobody thinks any of this stuff any more. It's just a thought experiment from spiritually evolved beings. For some reason in my mind I keep coming back to Amos Bronson Alcott's weird prophetic writings Tablets, which I haven't actually read, but I wonder about, and get flummoxed quite quickly reading a few pages. And I think about Sangharakshita in the Hindu ashram with the guy who took down dictation from God. Sangharakshita spent a lot of time with him, I was really surprised. I think I'd like to come up with my own cosmological imaginings. But mostly I just want to get on with the practice: Study, community, devotion, ethics and meditation. Included in this is the study of mind stretching books.
I think the mating brain is a supercomputer that is overclocked, and wants to do something, even if you're not into attracting a mate. I also enjoy a Jungian exploration of mythology. What is important? What are the foundation myths in the machine language of your brain?
Dwelling in Abhassara Brahma, "...there they dwell, mind-made, feeding on delight, self luminous, moving through the air, glorious--and they stay like that for a very long time."
Sounds like a pure land, not like the pure lands where your tongue covers everything, and there are all these jewels, and or the fantastical magic of The Life and Liberation of Padmasambhava, or the Lotus Sutra. I don't always speak California slang, but these books are far out, man.
We can choose what sacred writings to perfume our minds with. Is it true crime? Is it romance? Is it operation manuals? Is it investment strategies to grow wealth? Is it nutrition? I think a Buddhist will spend time with the word of the Buddha, the Buddhavacana, that miraculously is handed down to us through centuries. Every day I'm amazed that I get to read this stuff, and come across new concepts that launch my mind that is ready to be launched and reigned in.
The internet is devoted to manic pixie girls latest outfits, but there's not a lot on this: link: Abhassara. Wisdom Library.
Mind stretching is what spirituality is all about, the freedom of pushing boundaries. I don't like the language of transcendence because I look up instead of to my body. The body will lead you to enlightenment with all it's ramshackled questions. What do you keep coming back to?
Saturday, January 21, 2023
Where the Buddha tred
I'm reading the Long Discourses, and I wanted to see a map of the Buddha's times, where Rajagaha and Nalanda were:
Friday, January 20, 2023
Nirvana Beer
I mean yea, but don't I really expect an intoxicant to be accurate with language. I tend to think you can't blaspheme Buddhism. Buddhism is inside me, to the extent that I try and live up to the ideals, and practice the path. What others do isn't irrelevant, because we're all one, interconnected. It's pretty hard to police the non-enlightened chaos inside us and outside us.
Trying to police myself is a full time job, and there's no reason not to bring that fight out into the world, but it feels like over reach to me. Not everyone has the commitments I do, we live in a multicultural society. Not everyone is Buddhist. Most people are secular hedonist conformists.
For a business to casually stroll into my sacred garden of words and exploit that language... I feel just as violated by the low minimum wage and other aspects of capitalist exploitation. I think if Buddhist ideals were really put into a righteous government, there would be a universal income. We need to do more to curb global warming and honor the sacrifice of Bruce Alan Wynn.
Everyone is free to comment on everything. I take more offense to policies that harm people, that lead to death. It was estimated that 40% of the Covid deaths were attributable to Trump's policy. USA loses so many people to lax gun control I honestly try to blot that from my memory because it's so upsetting.
The battle is everywhere and the misuse of language is a huge aspect in the wrongness going on in America right now. That lying is "legitimate political discourse", and not an antisocial fuck you, well, that's just plain wrong to me, and there needs to be more repercussions. There's almost a game of who can be more deceptive and exploitative. And people celebrate that. I find that pretty disgusting and trivializing.
Culture may trivialize spiritual language, a beer wishes it could lead to a transcendent state, inhabits the word is if to take over and absorb the power of that word. If it truly could, then I'd be set. But that's just not how things are.
There used to be a good blog that chronicled "Dharma Burgers" where businesses used the language of Buddhism and images with their products. I find inspiration in seeing Buddhist images, and I'm not really tempted to use a bank if they use a Buddha image. But I do like when a Asian restaurant uses Buddhas in their decor because that sets a kind of tone, and I just take the positive from the world as much as I can.
As someone who has struggled with addiction and is in recovery, I'm going to stay away from beer anyway. Staying away from intoxicants is an essential part of the path where mindfulness is valued.
I was never going to buy that beer, though I used to like that brewery. They had one of my favorite beers, "3 Philosophers". I wasn't offended as a former philosophy major at them using the word philosophers. It's all pretty superficial. I don't look to beer can labels for accurate representations of reality. I almost expect them to lie like intoxication does.
That people trivialize language and throw it around in a retail situation doesn't seem unusual. I don't feel the sacred there, but mindfulness about consumerism and capitalism is a worthy thing. Mindfulness about the dangers of intoxicants is important too. I wouldn't cherry pick the name out of all the offensive things going on, personally, but I wish Fisher well, and think it's cool he got into this right wing newspaper for insisting on accuracy in language.
If Ommegang wants to be fun with language they should call a beer Intoxicant, Loosening Inhibitions, or Don't Drink and Drive. Liquid Courage or A Temporary Solution to Social Anxiety.
For me that path of drinking drains my energy, money and clouds my vision, and it's a poor choice for me. I'm fairly selfish and substance use leads to greater selfishness, that's going in the wrong direction. Generosity, empathy, love and kindness is the direction I want to go in.
“Monks, if anyone should speak in disparagement of me, of the Dhamma or of the Sangha, you should not be angry, resentful or upset on that account. If you were to be angry or displeased at such disparagement, that would only be a hindrance to you. For if others disparage me, the Dhamma or the Sangha, and you are angry or displeased, can you recognise whether what they say is right or not?” -DN1
Wednesday, January 18, 2023
Social media addiction
Thursday, January 12, 2023
Images
Thailand
Thursday, January 05, 2023
Itivuttaka 38
Friday, December 30, 2022
Poem
Want the change by Rainer Maria Rilke
(English version by Anita Barrows and Joanna Macy)
Want the change. Be inspired by the flame
where everything shines as it disappears.
The artist, when sketching, loves nothing so much
as the curve of the body as it turns away.
What locks itself in sameness has congealed.
Is it safer to be gray and numb?
What turns hard becomes rigid
and is easily shattered.
Pour yourself out like a fountain.
Flow into the knowledge that what you are seeking
finishes often at the start, and, with ending, begins.
Every happiness is the child of a separation
it did not think it could survive. And Daphne, becoming
a laurel,
dares you to become the wind.
Tuesday, December 27, 2022
Schadenfreude
I'm so slow, I make connections at a glacial pace. I was thinking about how I actually enjoy that that woman who had a meltdown about the Respect for Marriage Act. Missouri Republican Congresswoman Vicky Hartzler cried when she talked about how it would affect her to have her prejudices challenged.
Is it wrong for me to enjoy Hartzler's pain?
I think about Anakin he kills Count Dooku, "it's not the Jedi way." I mean I really believe in being authentic and that pretending to be enlightened isn't the way, but I'm interested in the guilt I have at schadenfreude. What is that guilt telling me? That getting my way (tolerance and acceptance of the whole spectrum of sexuality) and having someone suffer because they didn't get their way (forcing an inappropriate and ineffective way of being that harms others).
The insight I had today cooking my pasta with mushrooms, nuts and a marinara sauce was that is what I don't like about talk of karma. The schadenfreude of it. Similar to the "fucked around and found out" spirit in the fight for good and less good.
I have lost 3 friendships in the Trump years, and it's been really hard to have people basically lie to my face about an election, January 6th, and all that. I don't think a political perspective entitles you to be an asshole, like Abbott sending a bus full of immigrants to arrive at Kamala Harris' house on Xmas eve (NY Times). That's a really grimy thing to do and it would only be an ideological perspective that hides the cruelty of it. I don't want to in any way enjoy partisand shots, but I do like what I consider to be the triumph of good over less good.
I'm working for the alleviation of suffering of all beings through the very difficult discipline of Buddhism. So even when people I don't feel good about, suffer, I'm not as thrilled about that as I could be. (I hear the people in my life laughing at my pathetic attempts, but I still think I want that even if I am so pathetic.)
MSNBC video, that includes nephew Andrew Hartzler putting his aunt in her place. He points out that she's not being silenced, she can't put her "religion" on him. His parents sent him conversion therapy and when in college, he had more conversion therapy. How can you work to change people's desires?
Master Sheng-yen
There's a great documentary (1:15) about Master Sheng Yen. He was born in China and spread the Dharma to Queens New York. I'm always very impressed by spreaders of the Dharma. He left China and came to America to found a center. Amazing stuff.
I've visited his center in Elmhurst Queens. He came to the USA in 1975 with nothing. It must take great faith to go somewhere and set up a new sangha. There is much merit in such activities.
Saturday, December 24, 2022
Ajahn Chah
Ajahn Chah once said: "As far as I understand, Christianity teaches people to do good and avoid evil, just as Buddhism does, so what is the problem? However, if people are upset by the idea of celebrating Christmas, that can be easily remedied. We won't call it Christmas. Let's call it 'Buddhamas.' Anything that inspires us to see what is true and do what is good is proper practice. You may call it any name you like."
Thursday, December 22, 2022
Kitchen mindfulness
Winter solstice, I was cutting up onions, and I felt gratitude for Anandi teaching me her kitchen knowledge, which in part is mindfulness in the kitchen where I wasn't always mindful, and supported the cultural shift towards plant based diet.
I worked at Ponderosa Steak House in high school, and quickness was valued above anything. I learned the flip, rotate, flip method of putting hashes on meat. Restaurant work is hard work, I'm always kind to restaurant workers. The upshot for me was sometimes in the kitchen I can be a bit hurried and unmindful.
Lessons don't sink in right away, but do much later. Tasting as you cook is a learned skill. Poverty has shifted me into the kitchen even more.
I let my food cool down a little bit sometimes, don't want to burn the taste buds. I'm not sure if I've always been open to receiving feedback. Patience with other's autonomy is an important aspect of being in the kitchen with others.
I wish everyone a happy winter solstice. The shortest day of the year in NYC with a day length of 9:15:17. Days start getting longer tomorrow, December 22nd, 2022
Sunday, December 18, 2022
Saturday, December 10, 2022
Time
The cosmic view of time is utilized to open up the mind, how our lives are so short, and we can have a little more wisdom in our view of life, indeed, we could actually aim for enlightenment. A huge mountain where a bird flew over with a strip of silk, and that wearing down the mountain is how long a big unit of time takes. A kalpa. Or is it a mahakalpa? Obviously it's not scientific, it's spiritual image. We can't imagine how old the universe is, or time really. Living in the now might be a spiritual strategy to cope with anxiety and depression, but a larger view of time is also useful. The cosmic view can aid spirituality.
"light from the four galaxies took more than 13.4 billion years to reach Webb. More precisely, the telescope sees the galaxies as they looked only 350 million years after the Big Bang, when the universe was only 2% of its current age, although the galaxies must have started to form even earlier." (source) These new telescopes are looking far out into the universe, and into time, it's a similar kind of phenomenon.
I'm reading a fascinating book of essays by Benjamin Labatut called When We Cease To Understand The World. In the essay I'm reading now he's talking about the Schwarzschild singularity. Time bends around dense objects. Einstein got a letter from the front during WW1 from a academic who was dead by the time he got the letter, with elegant solutions to problems he couldn't even imagine yet. Unique and fascinating book came out in 2020. Short and recommended non-fiction essays. This is a book worth savoring.
I still find it amazing the Buddha who lived 2500 years ago has ideas that I have read about.
Thursday, December 08, 2022
Listening to talks on Madhyamaka
Madhyamaka is Nagarjuna's articulation of the Dharma.
These are short:
What is the Madhyamaka tradition? By Khenpo Jorden (YouTube) (5:22)
Madhyamaka: Jay Garfield (YouTube) (10:36)
Are all things empty? - Nagarjuna & The Buddhist Middle Way (YouTube) (22:36)
Nāgārjuna and Indian Madhyamaka (YouTube) (38:40) Derived from Jan Christoph Westerhoff, Richard Hayes, and Jay L. Garfield.
The upshot is that there is one thing, and that parts of it don't have separate existence.
Found a copy of the translation of the Mūlamadhyamakakārikā online:
1:1
Neither from itself nor from another,
Nor from both,
Nor without a cause,
Does anything whatever, anywhere arise. (Wikipedia)
2. There are four conditions: efficient condition;
Percept-object condition; immediate condition;
Dominant condition, just so.
There is no fifth condition.
3. The essence of entities
Is not present in the conditions, etc ….
If there is no essence,
There can be no otherness-essence.
(source)
Tuesday, December 06, 2022
Today is the day Ambedkar died
Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar lived 3 April 1952 – 6 December 1956. He was born untouchable in India. He would sit outside the classroom and look through the window to learn. He went to America and got a PhD and went to England and got a PhD, then went home to India to help write the constitution and become the country's first law justice minister in 1947. Later he decided he wasn't going to die a Hindu, no point in being untouchable, so he studied religion and decided on Buddhism. At his conversion to Buddhism he converts with many other untouchables. He created a liberation theology type movement where an oppressed class seeks to raise themselves out of poverty and poor social standing.
I've been friends with a fellow in Pune India, though correspondence, for many years. He was the secretary in the movement. He has a beautiful wife, bought a house for his family. He gave out supplies during Covid. He's a good guy, leads retreats now.
Naghabodhi's Jai Bhim! is one of many books about the ex-untouchables in India. Gandhi called them Dalit, god's children. Some people think that's not the term they want to use. Prerna Singh Bindra thinks it's a political stunt (source). Is it so hard to imagine ex-untouchable Hindus converting to Buddhism?
The Buddha and His Dhamma was Ambedkar's book on Buddhism, I have a copy of that book.
There's a lot of history in there, and I'm sure it's not as clean and simple as I present it. Ambedkar died 6 weeks after his conversion leaving a movement without a leader. Triratna set up an outpost. Sangharakshita was asked to perform the refuges and precepts. Sangharakshita was Theravadin then, and the custom is to have the most senior monk do it, so he referred Ambedkar to that monk. Later on Lokamitra went to England to help with the movement. He married a Dalit woman and has spent his life in service of the movement. There are other organizations. It's a fractured movement.
I'm just observing it and reading about it from New York. Every time I meet an Indian person, I ask if they know who Ambedkar is. The people in my neighborhood are from Gujarati, they've never heard of him. They're Hindu. I met a woman from Mumbai once, she was Muslim. She hadn't heard of Ambedkar. The Indians I met working on Long Island didn't know Ambedkar either. One guy I talked to told me Indians don't really know history of their country. He said his friends who watched the Ashoka movie, and they thought he should have kept fighting. One woman told me her father was a religious leader, and he said the castes are archetypes, bringing Jung into the mix.
As I've gotten older, I've gotten more patient and realistic, but I still hope for a classless, casteless society. of course there will still be hierarchy. I suppose I fantasize about a cashless future, like Star Trek where career fulfillment is the focus. Cultures of oppression will not be cherished, they will be eradicated.
I find the life of Ambedkar inspiring.
























































